For years, one of my main irritations was the fact that there was no clear definition of ‘the’ circular economy. This results in vagueness, omnipresence of the concept, circular washing and even people thinking we can simply replace striving for a sustainable economy with ‘circular economy’. But the itching is now under control.
In a short article published recently, Frank Figge, from ESCP Business School, along with Kedge Business School’s Andrea Stevenson Thorpe and Melissa Gutberlet, tried to clarify the mess of definitions that can be found in the literature.
The authors suggest four pertinent characteristics of a helpful definition:
- “First, a circular economy clearly stipulates closed resource loops, negating the need for virgin resource use. This is both a sufficient and necessary criterion.
- “Second, the optimisation of resource flows — and their direction — are necessary criteria. In a fully circular system, the outputs and inputs of resources must be the same. Some resource flows might therefore need to be reduced while others might need to be increased to ensure the supply and demand for pre-used resources match.
- “Third, as a necessary criterion, the circular economy is always distributed across at least two complementary levels that each follow a different logic. Resource circularity itself manifests at a higher level (e.g. across a cluster of firms or industries). Supporting such circularity are activities (e.g. recycling, remanufacturing, etc) with which actors (e.g. firms) engage at a lower level. In other words, a combination of lower-level activities creates higher level circularity.
- “Fourth, and as somewhat of a caveat, the laws of thermodynamics and the inevitability of human error mean that ‘perfect’ resource circularity is unlikely to emerge — and notions of such will remain an idealized concept. It also shows that the circular economy by itself is unlikely to deliver a steady state. Consequently, a plurality of approaches will be required to reduce economic resource use to a sustainable level.”
Circular economy principles will […] not deliver an economy within planetary boundaries.
The last characteristic is especially important: circular economy principles will in reality not lead to a steady state or sustainable economy! They will (thus) not deliver an economy within planetary boundaries.
Also important: a lot of the literature and practice concentrates on the supporting activities for circularity like recycling, not on checking if (higher level) circularity is achieved.
A clear definition is important. But in my humble opinion, this short article already has an important takeaway: a good definition of the circular economy implies that it is NOT a recipe for a continuous (green) growth agenda.
This article is based on a LinkedIn post (which generated many comments), and gives the views of its author, not the position of ESCP Business School.
License and Republishing
The Choice - Republishing rules
We publish under a Creative Commons license with the following characteristics Attribution/Sharealike.
- You may not make any changes to the articles published on our site, except for dates, locations (according to the news, if necessary), and your editorial policy. The content must be reproduced and represented by the licensee as published by The Choice, without any cuts, additions, insertions, reductions, alterations or any other modifications.If changes are planned in the text, they must be made in agreement with the author before publication.
- Please make sure to cite the authors of the articles, ideally at the beginning of your republication.
- It is mandatory to cite The Choice and include a link to its homepage or the URL of thearticle. Insertion of The Choice’s logo is highly recommended.
- The sale of our articles in a separate way, in their entirety or in extracts, is not allowed , but you can publish them on pages including advertisements.
- Please request permission before republishing any of the images or pictures contained in our articles. Some of them are not available for republishing without authorization and payment. Please check the terms available in the image caption. However, it is possible to remove images or pictures used by The Choice or replace them with your own.
- Systematic and/or complete republication of the articles and content available on The Choice is prohibited.
- Republishing The Choice articles on a site whose access is entirely available by payment or by subscription is prohibited.
- For websites where access to digital content is restricted by a paywall, republication of The Choice articles, in their entirety, must be on the open access portion of those sites.
- The Choice reserves the right to enter into separate written agreements for the republication of its articles, under the non-exclusive Creative Commons licenses and with the permission of the authors. Please contact The Choice if you are interested at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Extracts: It is recommended that after republishing the first few lines or a paragraph of an article, you indicate "The entire article is available on ESCP’s media, The Choice" with a link to the article.
Citations: Citations of articles written by authors from The Choice should include a link to the URL of the authors’ article.
Translations: Translations may be considered modifications under The Choice's Creative Commons license, therefore these are not permitted without the approval of the article's author.
Modifications: Modifications are not permitted under the Creative Commons license of The Choice. However, authors may be contacted for authorization, prior to any publication, where a modification is planned. Without express consent, The Choice is not bound by any changes made to its content when republished.
Authorized connections / copyright assignment forms: Their use is not necessary as long as the republishing rules of this article are respected.
Print: The Choice articles can be republished according to the rules mentioned above, without the need to include the view counter and links in a printed version.
If you choose this option, please send an image of the republished article to The Choice team so that the author can review it.
Podcasts and videos: Videos and podcasts whose copyrights belong to The Choice are also under a Creative Commons license. Therefore, the same republishing rules apply to them.