As employers grapple with labour shortages and the Great Resignation, they are turning to a growing trend: sourcing human capital from within the organisation. Quiet hiring has the potential to build a more engaged, productive and loyal workforce, but there are plenty of risks that organisations need to mitigate if they are to realize these benefits.
To provide some guidance, we spoke to ESCP professor Kerstin Alfes.
Professor of Managementat ESCP Business School
Human resources professionals will have grown accustomed to the term “quiet quitting” this past year, when employees do their job but just the bare minimum, putting life ahead of work. Now comes a new term in the HR lexicon: “quiet hiring”. The concept means filling vacant positions with existing employees, instead of going to the labour market to source talent.
The trend is not new, but it is gaining momentum, as the war for talent enters a new phase. Despite higher interest rates and inflation, unemployment is at record lows in many economies. Even as the technology and banking sectors announce layoffs, many companies continue to hire as vacancies remain high.
They are also grappling with the “Great Resignation”, when millions of people quit their jobs during the pandemic in search of better pay or conditions elsewhere. However, companies cannot find enough qualified staff, owing to an under-investment in skills development, and technology leading to rapid changes in the demand for specific occupations.
These challenges are pushing employers to look inwards instead of outwards for human capital, tapping people who they already employ. Quiet hiring enables businesses to plug holes in their workforce, far more quickly and cheaply. It can also benefit workers, boosting retention, engagement and productivity levels.
However, there is a dark side to quiet hiring, with some employers using it to exploit hard-working staff for additional labour, without offering extra compensation.
So, we sat down with Kerstin Alfes, professor of organisation and human resource management, to explore how organisations can make quiet hiring work for everyone.
Redistributing the division of labour
The simplest definition of quiet hiring is when an organisation acquires new skills without actually hiring anyone, saving substantially on costs. However, as Prof. Alfes explains, “it can mean taking on new tasks, not necessarily entire roles, as employers redistribute the division of activities”.
Multiple factors, including the rise of occupations that are cognitively more challenging and a labour market that has bounced back faster than expected from the impact of the pandemic, have contributed to the growth of internal mobility inside organisations.
And the trend is not simply a fad; it is here to stay, given the shortfall of workplace training in the past, Prof. Alfes predicts. “From a macro perspective, it will take years to fill the skill gap in the workforce,” she explains. One alternative is to increase the mobility of labour between different economies, but immigration remains a sensitive political subject in many countries.
In this context, employers are turning to quiet hiring as an alternative , Prof. Alfes points out.
Tangible benefits for the business world
That’s not to say the practice is without merit. Some companies are exploring quiet hiring with exciting results, Prof. Alfes tells us. “There are huge benefits. If we hire from within the organisation, employees already know the culture, processes and policies. So onboarding is a lot quicker, and the employee can reach full productivity much faster, delivering a return for the company. It’s also faster to find someone because you have a ready-made talent pool that has already been vetted and, in some cases, trained.”
In contrast, hiring a new employee can cost nearly $4,700 on average, according to the Society for Human Resource Management.
However, Prof. Alfes urges employers not to see quiet hiring as merely a cheap alternative to going to the labour market. “It’s lower cost, but also if it’s done well, it can be a strong motivational driver. Moving into different roles increases task variety and expands professional networks, while also giving the employee an opportunity to acquire new skills. So, it can also be part of your wider talent management strategy that positions you as an attractive employer, one that doesn’t lose staff to the Great Resignation.”
What’s in it for me?
Yet quiet hiring can also frustrate employees, who may be moving into roles they are not interested in; Prof. Alfes reminds us. “To make quiet hiring work for them, employees need to communicate what they want out of the transition. They should be asking: what’s in it for me?”
The biggest risk is that employees feel like they are being exploited, she adds, so companies need to make sure they are fairly compensating staff for taking on additional tasks and responsibilities.
In addition, Prof. Alfes advises employers to think carefully about the long-term development of their staff, rather than dumping extra work on them just to fill an immediate hiring need. “It should not be an ad-hoc approach; it should be part of a wider strategic plan for human capital management.”
Finally, she says the starting point is investing in training and development for the existing workforce, so they have the capabilities that are needed to fill vacant positions, and can hit the ground running when they begin new roles. “Having invested in training before is a key success factor, so that people have adequate knowledge, skills and abilities to move fluidly between tasks and jobs, as the workplace becomes a more flexible space.”
License and Republishing
The Choice - Republishing rules
We publish under a Creative Commons license with the following characteristics Attribution/Sharealike.
- You may not make any changes to the articles published on our site, except for dates, locations (according to the news, if necessary), and your editorial policy. The content must be reproduced and represented by the licensee as published by The Choice, without any cuts, additions, insertions, reductions, alterations or any other modifications.If changes are planned in the text, they must be made in agreement with the author before publication.
- Please make sure to cite the authors of the articles, ideally at the beginning of your republication.
- It is mandatory to cite The Choice and include a link to its homepage or the URL of thearticle. Insertion of The Choice’s logo is highly recommended.
- The sale of our articles in a separate way, in their entirety or in extracts, is not allowed , but you can publish them on pages including advertisements.
- Please request permission before republishing any of the images or pictures contained in our articles. Some of them are not available for republishing without authorization and payment. Please check the terms available in the image caption. However, it is possible to remove images or pictures used by The Choice or replace them with your own.
- Systematic and/or complete republication of the articles and content available on The Choice is prohibited.
- Republishing The Choice articles on a site whose access is entirely available by payment or by subscription is prohibited.
- For websites where access to digital content is restricted by a paywall, republication of The Choice articles, in their entirety, must be on the open access portion of those sites.
- The Choice reserves the right to enter into separate written agreements for the republication of its articles, under the non-exclusive Creative Commons licenses and with the permission of the authors. Please contact The Choice if you are interested at contact@the-choice.org.
Individual cases
Extracts: It is recommended that after republishing the first few lines or a paragraph of an article, you indicate "The entire article is available on ESCP’s media, The Choice" with a link to the article.
Citations: Citations of articles written by authors from The Choice should include a link to the URL of the authors’ article.
Translations: Translations may be considered modifications under The Choice's Creative Commons license, therefore these are not permitted without the approval of the article's author.
Modifications: Modifications are not permitted under the Creative Commons license of The Choice. However, authors may be contacted for authorization, prior to any publication, where a modification is planned. Without express consent, The Choice is not bound by any changes made to its content when republished.
Authorized connections / copyright assignment forms: Their use is not necessary as long as the republishing rules of this article are respected.
Print: The Choice articles can be republished according to the rules mentioned above, without the need to include the view counter and links in a printed version.
If you choose this option, please send an image of the republished article to The Choice team so that the author can review it.
Podcasts and videos: Videos and podcasts whose copyrights belong to The Choice are also under a Creative Commons license. Therefore, the same republishing rules apply to them.
